I am interested in purchasing a semi-auto shotgun. I have narrowed it down to the Beretta or the Benelli montefeltro. The shop people suggest that the Benelli is more reliable. Could you comment on both guns and their differences. It just gets me in trouble. I disagree with your shop people I do not feel that the Benelli is any more reliable that than the It is reliable in different ways.

The Benelli works very well in harsh weather and after a total immersion baptism. The Benelli also shoots very clean because it is not a gas operated mechanism. It operates on the short recoil theory.

franchi vs beretta vs benelli

The Benellis all seem to kick harder than the s because of this. Also, depending on the model, the Benellis are less likely to function reliably with standard and light target ammunition. Not only do they kick more, but they also need heavier shells to work reliably. These guns were built for the hotter hunting loads. With those they work very reliably. As to reliability, it also pays to do a reality test.

Naturally they will seem to last longer. Benellis do shoot cleaner which is why the outfitters like thembut they do break the occasional part just like anything else. The Beretta autos are the clear choice when it comes to shooting clays. Just take a look at the gun racks at any major shoot.

The number of Benellis you see will equal the number of Alfa Romeo Gran Prix cars you see in the parking lot. The Berettas will equal the number of Fords. The Beretta or is clearly THE choice of autos for clay shooting today. No question about it. The has become ubiquitous in clay shooting because it currently has the best combination of balance, options, reliability and low recoil.

Many of the people I know who shoot s in competition can afford anything they want. They pick the because they simply shoot it better than anything else. I think that the Remington and Browning autos have a bit less kick. It just seems to have hit the right point for most people.

Officeworks launceston email

This area of functioning with all shells, light to heavy, is a big advantage of the Beretta over the Benellis if you shoot clays.Back to top. View in: Desktop. Home Forums Recruiting Pick'em LSU Football Schedule. Sign In Register. Outdoor Board. Page 1 2. Page 1 of 2. Franchi Affinity or Beretta A? Narrowed my shotgun search to these two. Which one does the OB recommend?


Personally I think the Franchi feels better but mainly because it's lighter. Replies Options Top. Obviously the biggest difference is the Affinity uses an inertia system with a similar action to Benelli and A uses a gas system.

Thomas truss

Beretta is the parent company of both and by most indications you cannot go wrong buying any of the 3. Most folks on the board will say that you should buy which one fits you best. Replies 1. I don't know anything about them, but based on safety location alone, I would go with the Franchi. The Beretta safety is at the front of the trigger guard and that throws me off.

Replies 0. Just sold my AAccording to the latest data distributed by the ATF, over 1. The vast majority of those shotguns were produced by Mossberg and Remington. Inovershotguns were imported into the US, falling to just overin Forthe top import country of manufacture for shotguns was Turkey, followed by Italy and then China in the third slot.

The fourth position was Brazil, with 58, shotguns imported. The numbers rapidly drop off from there, with Russia at 21, import now largely banned and no other country exceeded 7, units imported. Unfortunately, the "Made in USA" moniker is sorely misused. Beretta of Italy is one of the worst offenders, calling their "Made in USA," yet shipping them with Turkish barrels.

All you have to do is refer to the ATF data: ina grand total of shotguns were imported into the United States from Japan.

franchi vs beretta vs benelli

Browning does not primarily import shotguns from Japan; they import parts. The "Made in Italy" moniker is also misused, for it is not unusual to have a shotgun manufactured in Turkey, run it through the Italian proof house and then call it "Made in Italy. There are countless e-mails and phone calls every year asking about the best shotgun, the best shotgun for shooting clays, the best for hunting, and so forth.

Adidas superstar 2020

There is no easy, glib answer, for many of us are more price conscious than brand loyal. We should all "beware of the man with one gun," for that unfortunate fellow has no clue about shotguns or firearms in general and is perpetually clueless about using the right tool for the job. Yes, beware the man with one gun and also beware the man with one screwdriver. I will go down the line with a few comments about prominent models of autoloading twelve gauge shotguns.

My comments are not designed to change the mind of the man with one gun, if he actually has one, but just might provide some food for thought. At one time, despite Beretta's weak warranty and generally deplorable customer service, Beretta shotguns were a favorite of mine.

Unfortunately, in general, those days are long gone. In a rare burst of honesty, the American Rifleman magazine staff commented referring to an A beretta"That being said, the center of the shot pattern was noticeably low and right of the point of aim.

Essentially, Beretta enhances the wood's natural appearance through the application of an oil finish. The Grade-2 walnut on the evaluation sample exhibited noteworthy grain; however, the finish was not consistent, leaving many areas that appeared to be comparatively dry.

When shotguns do not shoot where they are pointed, no one should pay a premium. Noteworthy fake wood grain is something that must now be breaking new ground. After the tremendous problems with the A broken gas pistons, bad bolt buffers, bad shell lifters, incomprehensible fore-end nut, etc. Although the prices are not dropping, the amount of plastic, unfinished parts, poor machining and haphazard fit and finish in current Beretta product is astonishing.

Allegedly, Beretta is the flagship brand of all the Beretta Corporation brands Benelli, Beretta, Franchi, Stoegerbut that flag is sagging, if not sinking. Benelli inertia guns are a known quantity and although they are a bit proudly priced, they are backed by a good warranty and very good customer service. Inertia short recoil operated guns kick more than gas autos and yes, several gas autos handle a wider spectrum of loads.

Nor is the old inertia action a Benelli exclusive, as Browning, Weatherby, Girsan and others now have inertia guns that work well.

Benelli vs. Beretta

The Franchi inertia guns, essentially the Stoeger version made correctly, are now produced at the Benelli-Urbino facility and with the exception of the peculiarly notched, hard to replace recoil pad, are desirable guns.

For the low initial cost, the Mossberg 12 gauge autoloader to beat.Beretta vs. Benelli vs. Moderator: Rev. Posted: Mon May 18, pm. So, I am interested in replacing my aging Remmy with a new semi from one of the aforementioned gunmakers. If it helps, my requirements are for a light weight semiauto for upland use, and occasional waterfowling, easy to clean, reliable with various loads.

De nijs overhoeks

I am aware of what each brand costs and am willing to open the wallet. But, if I can get the same features cheaper? Frankly, it's been hard for me to accurately quantify the differences.

What say the hive mind here? Thanks, in advance, for your feedback! You will note right off that everyone has their personal favorite. They will defend their favorites to the death.

Find one of the brands you mentioned that feels good to you and buy it. IMHO, there is little difference in them as far as longetivity and reliability are concerned. I wouldn't turn around twice for the difference in them. If weight is important, there is a lightweight in each of those brands. All three brands are tried and true. The inertia actions are easier to clean and keep clean than the gas models. Roll the dice and pick the gun that feels the best to you.

My favorite gun of that family of brands is the Franchi 48, a long recoil action that has been an upland favorite since I can't say that it will be what you want. I like it and have used it for many years satisfactorily. I am not a Benelli fan so won't comment on that one, but do like both the Beretta and the Franchi.

My choice would be Beretta than the Franchi. Of all the guns I own, that are non-trap guns, the Beretta is my favorite when it comes to field guns. Honestly, you won't go wrong with either of the three. Guess I will lean more to the gas operated. It all depends on what you think you will enjoy the most.

Posted: Tue May 19, am. I was in the same boat last Summer. I was all set to buy a new primary waterfowling semi and give my old vintage a break. I went to the shows and shops, I handled everything, I shot everything anyone would let me at the club, I looked on line, I roamed GunBroker. Finally, in September I pulled the trigger and did it.

I got another What can I say, nothing else feels as good to me, except an Wingmaster, and I already had one of those, too.

Based on your requirements it would be the Benelli.Always have. I own three different semi-auto models; they're the only shotguns I've owned I saw a local ad for Password Home Forums Advertise. Likes Received I love Benelli shotguns. I wondered if it was a fake ad, since the price was insanely low; but we agreed to meet in the a.

He said he used it last season of waterfowling a couple of times and it showed. Just a beautiful shotgun. I've read many forums about guys who own both and still say pay the extra for a Benelli because it is just built better, nicer, etc.

Side-by-side, I cannot agree.

franchi vs beretta vs benelli

To me, after breaking them down, their fit-n-finish seems about as comparable as it gets, designs aside. So, not certain what those guys are referring to, in all honesty. Anyway, I took it out and fired all types of loads through the Improved Cylinder only: light-to-medium Target loads, Royal buckshot and Federal slugs; each went off without a hitch.


Now here's the odd thing, I feel like the Franchi handled recoil from the buckshot and slugs every bit as good, if not maybe slightly better, than the SBE2's ComforTech stock.

My shoulder today feels just fine was shooting wearing nothing but a tee-shirt. Admittedly, I only shot a few rounds through the Benelli for comparison, but I loaded them up together and shot one after the other with the more brutal loads.

After that, it was all Franchi. I never thought I'd say this, but I think I like shooting the Franchi better. It is one hell of a shotgun.

I know the Affinity has received accolades for years; and rightly so. Franchi has me sold. A terrific performing scatter gun. Great buy! Thanks for the input. Since they are another Beretta holdings company I guess it's a little expected. Thanks guys. No, I am aware of the histories of both firearms and their affiliations with one another; I was just trying to articulate that I never thought I'd enjoy the Franchi over any Benelli as much as I did e.These weapons are not only more expensive than most other Franchis, but also offer superior aesthetics and performance.

One of the most impressive things about this line is how many options are available. Besides for offering four distinct models, you can find Instinct shotguns chambered in 12, 20, 28, and. By the end of this piece, you should be able to determine whether or not the Instinct is right for you.

Picking the right Instinct is no easy task; each of these models features nuanced differences and special abilities. Starting with its design, Franchi outfitted this model with some of the classiest and stylish components, including a gold-plated trigger and an A-grade satin walnut stock.

Additionally, Franchi incorporated an easy to use and convenient tang-mounted safety with a built-in barrel selector to allow for quick changes on the fly. Plus, to give it a more natural feel, they added a perfectly texturized slim pistol grip and forend. These features, combined with their instinctive fiber optic sight system, provide a more reliable and accurate experience dropping birds and clays. Franchi really hit the nail on the head when they named this shotgun the Instinct — its ideal weight delivers great balance and its handcrafted-build shoulders smoothly, making it easier than ever to pinpoint fast moving targets.

While this version contains a higher grade walnut stock, its aluminum alloy receiver is not nearly as durable as the steel L model. That being said, if you shoot regularly, it may not be a good idea to rely on the aluminum receiver. Once again, this model forces you to make another trade-off. That is, while the SL swings faster due to its lower weight, you will definitely feel the increased recoil with this shotgun.

Like the L variant, the Franchi SL also comes with their popular auto ejectors, chrome-lined barrel, auto safety, barrel selector and a wide variety of chokes. The newest Instinct offered by Franchi is their Sporting model, developed with competitive trap and skeet shooters in mind.

Beautiful day for a dove hunt! With my beautiful franchiinstinct. Last but not least is the Instinct Catalyst, designed specifically for female shooters. Overall, this proved to be a profitable and popular decision for Franchi. Once I got my hands on the Franchi Instinct, someone at the range proceeded to lecture me on how his Weatherby Orion is a much better firearm. After giving it a try, I was very impressed, to say the least. The Orion is not only more affordable, it also contains most of the popular features of the Instinct and more!

Besides for their automatic ejectors, A-grade walnut stock, and ventilated top rib, the Weatherby also features an ambidextrous top tang safety and Prince of Wales texturized grip. Beretta is renowned for their excellence in gunsmithing and especially scatterguns, so it should come to no surprise how impressive this model is. My only problem with reviewing this premium firearm is whether to start with its stunning makeup or unmatched performance.

Between its cone-shaped locking lugs and cold hammer forged barrel, the was built to last! The low profile, outstanding balance, easy swing, and integrated Mobile bore barrel of the Beretta produce one hell of a shooting experience.

Sorry Franchi, better luck next time. Sam is an avid firearms enthusiast who loves sharing his knowledge and experience with fellow gunivores. Hey thanks for the review.

I was looking at a SL but may look at the L. One thing for me is this line fits me and I am hard to fit.Beretta A 5. Beretta A vs Franchi Affinity. Hi guys, this is my first time here and would like to know your preference between these two guns.

I know the Franchi is Inertia and the Beretta is gas and I have extensively researched both and know exactly how both work, but operation isn't a factor here and neither is fit not because I don't care about fit, but because they both feel fine. I'm wondering which you think is a little nicer or a little higher quality or which one is finished a little nicer.

And which would you prefer for recreational backyard clays, upland, and some waterfowl. I also know that Inertia guns typically recoil harder than gas guns, but if you have shot either or botha comparison of the recoil to another shotgun RemingtonMossbergBrowning BPS, BerettaWinchester SX3, comparison of the Beretta and the Franchi, or whatever, I don't care a comparison would be nice. Thank you.


Re: Beretta A vs Franchi Affinity. The only real difference is the operating system, both use mobil chokes, both have shims, and both come in a variety of barrel lengths. The Affinity is lighter to me and points so much better. The Affinity is Inertia operated, has a higher rib, chrome chamber and bore, made in Italy, 7yr warranty, better fit and finish and 3 chokes and shims. The finish on the barrel of mine is rough, like it had been sand blasted prior to bluing, the butt stock is easily compressed at the sides of the recoil pad.

Reading thru the manual that came with mine, I really cannot tell you the warranty, although I have read it is 5yrs. It really comes down to how it fits you and whether you want gas or inertia, because either one will serve you equally. Although I am not pleased with the barrel finish on my A, it hasn't given me any trouble.

Bought a 12 ga Max 4 Affinity before this season, after narrowing the choice to the same two you're considering. I love it. Tremendous feel, swings and points like a dream and patterns steel great. Any difference in felt recoil between inertia system and gas is minimal. I shot a BPS and mags for many years and the Affinity recoil is nothing by comparison.

thoughts to “Franchi vs beretta vs benelli

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *